How to make French press coffee that is not muddy
French press is full-bodied and simple. The two things that go wrong are a grind that is too fine and leaving the coffee sitting on the grounds.
- Coffee
- 30 g
- Water
- 450 g
- Grind
- Coarse
- Water temp
- 93 to 96 °C
- Steep
- 4 min
A French press steeps the coffee in water, then separates it with a metal mesh. The mesh lets fine particles and natural oils through, which gives the cup a heavier body than paper filtered coffee. It also means grind size matters. Too fine and the cup turns silty and bitter.
The recipe
This uses a ratio of 1 part coffee to 15 parts water, a little stronger than pour-over because the cup is full-bodied. It suits a small press.
- Preheat the press. Rinse it with hot water, then pour the water out. A cold glass pulls the temperature down.
- Grind 30 g of coffee coarse, close to coarse sea salt. Add it to the press.
- Add 450 g of water just off the boil, about 93 to 96 °C. Pour so every part of the coffee gets wet, and start your timer as you pour.
- Stir gently once with a spoon, then set the lid on top with the plunger still up. This keeps the heat in.
- At 4:00, break the crust. Stir the top a couple of times, then spoon off the foam and floating grounds if you like a cleaner cup.
- Press slowly. Push the plunger down steadily over about 20 seconds. If it fights you, the grind is too fine.
- Pour it all out right away. Coffee left sitting on the grounds keeps extracting and turns bitter. Pour what you will not drink into a thermos or a second mug.
If the cup tastes off
- Muddy or silty: grind coarser, and let the cup rest for a minute so fine particles settle. Do not drink the last few sips.
- Sour or thin: steep a little longer, or grind slightly finer, or use hotter water.
- Bitter or harsh: shorten the steep to 3:30, or grind coarser.
A note on filtered and unfiltered coffee
Unfiltered coffee such as French press carries more of the coffee oils than paper-filtered coffee. One of them, cafestol, has been linked to higher LDL cholesterol in studies of heavy unfiltered coffee drinkers. If you have been told to watch your cholesterol, ask your doctor about it. Paper filters remove most of these oils.
Cleaning
Old coffee oils turn rancid and make every cup taste stale. Take the plunger apart, rinse the screen and wash it with warm soapy water. Do not rinse grounds down the sink drain; knock them into the bin or compost.
Gear for this
Some links on this site are, or may become, affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It does not change what we write. Details.
French press
Look for a glass or steel body and a plunger screen that comes apart for cleaning.
Burr grinder
A coarse, even grind is the biggest upgrade for French press.
Kitchen scale
Weigh the coffee and the water for repeatable cups.